Showing posts with label IGN. Show all posts
Showing posts with label IGN. Show all posts

Thursday, April 28, 2011

IGN Asks: Is Yoshi Gay?

An interesting item came across my newsfeed today via GJAIF. Titled "Fake or Gay: Yoshi and Turok" it is a short IGN piece trying to reason if Yoshi and Turok's... Turok are gay. GJAIF said this article would offend many people in the LGBT club and I'm not sure if it does, although it could have certainly been worse. I think the author is gay but they never actually say it, preferring to write "I'm qualified to speak on such matters because I'm pretty much the Perez Hilton of IGN, minus the pink hair, bad attitude, and like 60 lbs."

Despite it mostly seeming like a piece of short fluff, some interesting points were addressed in the article that do bother me. For one, the idea that if Birdo is a transwoman that means Yoshi is in a gay relationship. Yes, they do say "technically queer" but then I don't even really know what that means. Damn you LGBT community always coming up with new terms for things or me just being really out of the loop.

Regardless, calling Yoshi gay at all because he is dating a transwoman is an idea I encounter a lot. Well, not with Yoshi particularly but in general. As a transman currently dating a woman I know I might very well throw a fit if someone said I was in a "gay relationship" with her because it isn't! If I'm dating a guy then, yes, that's gay. But if someone is presenting themselves as a woman/man/etc, then for all intents and purposes they are a woman/man/etc. Are you a doctor treating them? If not, then what reason do you have to evaluate and mark someone as to their birth gender? If someone is presenting one way there's no need to go back and find out what "they really are".

If Birdo were just a crossdresser than Birdo would be a man. A man who likes to crossdress. If Yoshi dated him then he would be in a gay relationship. However, being apparently a transwoman then Birdo is a woman and she's in a perfectly heterosexual dinosaur relationship. As for what might go on behind closed doors... well, I'd prefer to imagine that nobody in the Mushroom Kingdom is sexually active.

Really, that's much more than needed to be said for such a tiny article played off for laughs. Maybe.


Edit: For those interested in a larger discussion on Birdo and this article, check out this GayGamer post!
Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...